7 Bingeable Podcasts for Spooky Season

7 Bingeable Podcasts for Spooky Season

  • By Chris Alexis
  • October 23, 2024

From the eerie corners of Ohio, to across the pond and beyond - check out these 7 bingeable podcasts for spooky season!

With Halloween around the corner, many people are shining their digital flashlights into the dark, looking for something to give them a fright. But what kind of content gives you that right sense of dread?

Perhaps it’s true crime, urban legends, or supernatural tales. No matter what pulls you in, we have podcasts that are perfect for getting you into the Halloween spirit. Enjoy spooky season as the terror of the following programs creeps into your ears and tantalizes your brain…

Mary & Bill: An Ohio Cold Case

In a dark moment in Columbus, Ohio, a horrific crime played out in 1970 that would haunt the city forever. Mary and Bill, two university students deeply in love, were brutally murdered.

And the case remains unsolved to this day.

In this gripping podcast, host and producer Justin Glanville peels back the curtain on terrifying details, interviewing friends and witnesses who still shake from the memory of that fateful night.

With the sisters of the victims by his side, they confront the dark secrets that have lingered for 50 years. What really happened to Mary and Bill? Join them as they explore the nightmarish reality of unsolved murders and the desperate quest for justice in a case shrouded in death and despair.

FruitLoops: Serial Killers of Color

FruitLoops has nothing to do with breakfast cereal and everything to do with the often-overlooked narratives of serial killers of color.

Wendy and Beth's podcast peels back the layers of darkness in the criminal mind, challenging deep-rooted stereotypes while revealing unnerving truths.

Are you ready for them? The Seattle Shoelace Slasher is a real monster, and you need to hear about him. In “E199: SERIAL KILLER - Dewayne Lee Harris,” they explore the terrifying story of a man who brutally killed at least three women in the late 90s.

Take a deep breath, hit play, and witness truth…

Ain't It Scary with Sean and Carrie

Some people like their horror mixed with humor and heart. Is that you? Carrie and Sean McCabe offer two sides that will give you different perspectives:

He's skeptical. She's spooky. Who’s right?

You decide. Who will get into your head more? Who do you want to get into your head?

Their hour-long episodes blend chilling tales with an engaging storytelling style, making even the freakiest stories feel approachable…but not too comfortable.

After all, there’s a reason the podcast is called “Ain't It Scary” … Because it is!

Ohio Mysteries

Within the dark pages of Ohio's history, an unsettling podcast reveals dark mysteries. The tales of perplexing disappearances and unsolved homicides continue to haunt the minds of investigators…and listeners.

Exploring the eerie depths of Ohio's mysteries, they delve into the beasts that prowl the wilderness, the legends of cursed treasures hidden underground, and astonishing accounts of UFO sightings that leave witnesses wildly unnerved.

Among the most unsettling tales is that of 500 Parisian settlers who discovered their new American land deeds were worthless—an eerie reminder of lost dreams and vanished hope. In one gripping episode, “Ep. 211 - The French 500,” the unsettling fate of 500 Parisian settlers unravels, revealing a haunting Ohio mystery that lingers in anxiety-ridden ambiguity.

Carol Costello Presents: Blind Rage

Here’s another exciting choice for the true-crime addicts. In this unnerving podcast, journalist Carol Costello delves into the harrowing first assignment she faced as a 22-year-old rookie reporter: the brutal attack on Phyllis Cottle.

Often referred to by psychologists as “Triumphant Survivors,” Phyllis Cottle defied the label. She transformed her trauma into a force for change, using the horrific crime that nearly shattered her life to forge a new reality—not just for herself, but for everyone around her. What dark depths did she face, and how did she rise from the ashes of terror?

Conning the Con

Looking for a gripping and addictive story?

Andrew’s carefully crafted plans take an unexpected turn when Emma, his unsuspecting partner, uncovers his true identity. The chaos that ensues shakes their reality, forcing both to face the fallout of a confidence game gone wrong.

As the stakes rise, Conning the Con explores the tense dynamics between these two as they navigate a dangerous journey, each vying for victory in a high-stakes battle of trust and manipulation.

The Empty Coffin

Dive headfirst into the eerie and unknown with The Empty Coffin. Hosted by Greg Hansberry, a seasoned media professional and Halloween influencer, this upcoming podcast promises a weekly haunt of all things paranormal, supernatural, folklore, and delightfully spooky.

Expect a perfect blend of storytelling and interviews, exploring what frightens you yet keeps you intrigued…after all, isn’t that the experience you’re chasing?

Keep Reading

Columbus Radio Personality, Greg Hansberry, Unveils Spooktacular New Podcast, The Empty Coffin

Shows

Greg Hansberry, former Sunny This Morning host, launches The Empty Coffin, Columbus' only locally produced paranormal podcast.

Read Full Post

What Really Happened to Chad... Was It Truly Disturbing?

Podcasting

Since Evergreen took over the Disturbed podcast, we've been flooded with hundreds of inquiries about Chad... so we brought him back—just for a bit.

Read Full Post

Unlock Your Dark Side: Start Here with 5 Chilling Episodes of Disturbed: True Horror Stories

Shows

Discover the top 5 most chilling episodes of Disturbed: True Horror Stories, perfect for true horror fans seeking real and disturbing tales.

Read Full Post

Killer Podcasts Show Announcement

Shows

KillerPodcasts introduces a new collection of shows in all-things paranormal and true crime. Listen to the bizarre wherever you listen to podcasts.

Read Full Post